People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Ordered online food was still nice and warm even ordered creme brulee with ice cream! Everything was DELICIOUS! Definitely recommend and I will be fighting the urge to go so often lol! ”
“ First time at Premier Meat Pies in Renton—and what a find! Street parking only, but I lucked out with a spot right near the entrance. I tried the classic Scotch pie with mashed potatoes and gravy. It wasn't the crispiest crust, but the savory beef, rich gravy, and creamy mash made every bite super satisfying. The tomato basil soup was comforting and flavorful, and the cherry berry pie with fresh blueberries was the perfect sweet-tart finish. Both the pie crust and the dessert crust are a little undercooked. I wish it had been a little more crispy. Shoutout to Susie for her warm, friendly service—she made the experience even better. Cozy, clean, and relaxed vibe. If you’re in Renton and craving something hearty and homemade, this spot is a must! ”
“ Happy. This place makes me happy. It might be the food coma I feel after eating their Mac and Cheese Float (Tillamook Mac and cheese pie floated in tomato basil soup). Atmosphere is bright with soft rock music. There are several tvs with sports ”
“ Food, drinks, and service we're all outstanding. First, the decor is welcoming and comfortable. The long list of specialty cocktails has something for everyone and they are both fanciful and delicious. The meat pies and toppers are just the right size to satisfy, and with perfect crispy, decadent crusts that stayed crisp throughout. The Irish stew was one of the best I've had, and the bangers and mash was as good as any you would get overseas. Highly recommended. A fantastic new addition to the Renton Downtown! To add, they have a fantastic happy hour menu, and rotating daily specials. Kids eat free on Mondays, which is pretty great if you have a family. ”
“ Yum!! My boyfriend and I stopped by when we were waking around downtown Renton. The shop was really clean, someone greeted us as soon as we came in, and our to-go order was ready in literally like 2 minutes. I’ve only been to one other meat pie place in Burien, which is more like a calzone style pie that you hold and eat, so that’s what I expected, but Premier Meat Pies was more like a mini pie! My bf and I didn’t get to eat the pie until an hour later because we were running errands, but it held up well and tasted super delicious when we got to it. The filling included beef, gravy, peas, carrots, and was topped with mashed potatoes. Forgot to take a picture until I had already eaten half. There was also a side of cream included with the to go pie. Would stop by again! ”
“ Not your average meat pie joint. With the selection of pies combined with toppers and sides, it’s really fun. And delicious, everything was perfectly prepared and fresh. Great staff & service, fun inviting atmosphere, and great drinks, as well. Highly recommend. ”
“ We arrived with a small group of people (10) and the waitstaff was able to accomodate our group with seating and service that didn't miss a beat. 80% of our group were "first-timers" at Premier Meat Pies and loved it, vowing to return again. The pies are big enough to eat half of and finish up for dinner! AMAZING value, FANTASTIC ambiance and DELICIOUS food! ”
“ Such great food and amazing service! Suzy (Susie?) is such a gem. All the pies are delicious, and the chili is also yummy. You can't go wrong! And don't sleep on the cocktails! ”
Menu
Mashed Potatoes
US$4.99Sausage Roll
US$15.99Sweet Pies
US$12.99Coffee Cake
US$8.99Ice Cream 1 Scoop
US$5.99
About
Premier Meat Pies
Welcome to Premier Meat Pies, a delightful culinary gem located at 919 S 3rd St, Renton, WA 98057 that promises a unique and heartwarming dining experience. This brand is all about celebrating the classic comfort of meat pies, freshly crafted to satisfy your cravings in a cozy atmosphere.
From the moment you step into Premier Meat Pies, you’re greeted with a warm ambiance that feels both inviting and relaxed. The decor is bright, accompanied by soft rock music, creating the perfect backdrop for enjoying hearty homemade meals that echo the richness of traditional recipes.
- Exceptional Menu: The all-day menu showcases a variety of options including the classic Scotch pie, bangers and mash, and an enticing Mac & Cheese Float, which presents Tillamook mac and cheese pie beautifully suspended in a vibrant tomato basil soup. Each dish is crafted to deliver a robust flavor that keeps customers returning for more.
- Customer Favorites: Diners rave about the comforting beef and bean chili and the seasonal soups that offer a perfect pairing alongside the signature meat pies. Not to mention the indulgent cherry berry pie—fresh blueberries tucked in a delightful crust that provides the ideal sweet-tart finish to your meal.
- Friendly Service: The staff at Premier Meat Pies, particularly Susie, are known for their warm hospitality which further enhances the enjoyable dining experience. Customers frequently mention feeling welcomed and taken care of, adding to the charm of this establishment.
- Speedy Service: Many patrons have praised the efficiency of the service, with to-go orders prepared in minutes while still maintaining quality and flavor—making it a fantastic option for those on the go.
Customer reviews reflect a consistently positive sentiment. One customer, Nami N., described their experience as “a find,” showcasing their satisfaction with the savory fillings and comforting sides. Similarly, Roxanne Castro couldn't resist the delicious offerings, calling it a spot worth frequenting—an endorsement of Premier Meat Pies' culinary allure.
In summary, Premier Meat Pies stands out in Renton with its delightful selection of hearty dishes, a warm atmosphere, and excellent service. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking comfort food that calls to both nostalgia and appetite. Whether you're diving into a savory pie or enjoying a sweet dessert, you’ll leave with a content heart and a satisfied palate. Don’t miss the chance to discover why this quaint eatery is becoming a beloved staple in the local dining scene!
Book a table